FARGO, North Dakota — Cody Plumlee became the subject of a major criminal case following the December 2020 death of his girlfriend, Kirsten Knaus, in Fargo. The incident led to his arrest and a murder charge, but the case ultimately ended with a jury finding him not guilty of murder in April 2022.

The verdict is an important part of the story. Although prosecutors pursued serious charges connected to Knaus’s death, Plumlee was convicted of three other offenses: theft of property, providing false information to law enforcement and reckless driving.

Years after the case, renewed online interest has prompted questions about the incident, the trial’s outcome, his prison sentence and his current whereabouts.

What Happened to Kirsten Knaus?

The incident occurred on December 7, 2020, at a residence on 26th Street North in Fargo. According to court documents described in reporting by Valley News Live, police responded to a disturbance involving Plumlee and Knaus.

The couple had reportedly argued over keys to a vehicle they both used. A witness told investigators that Plumlee pushed Knaus down and left with the vehicle.

The witness further alleged that Plumlee returned approximately 45 minutes later, forced his way into the residence and pushed Knaus down a flight of stairs. She lost consciousness and sustained a severe brain injury.

Knaus was hospitalized and placed on life support. She later died after being taken off life support.

Plumlee reportedly told investigators that he pushed Knaus after she struck him in the forehead with a frying pan. That account formed part of the evidence discussed during the criminal proceedings.

Why Was Cody Plumlee Arrested?

Plumlee was initially arrested following the December 2020 incident. The original allegations included aggravated domestic assault, burglary, vehicle theft and fleeing from police.

After Knaus died, prosecutors added a murder charge in February 2021.

The case attracted significant attention because of the circumstances surrounding Knaus’s injuries and the disagreement between the prosecution’s allegations and Plumlee’s account of the confrontation.

What Was the Outcome of Cody Plumlee’s Murder Trial?

Plumlee’s trial took place in Cass County, North Dakota, in March and April 2022.

On April 7, 2022, Valley News Live reported that a jury found him not guilty of several serious charges, including:

  • Murder.

  • Aggravated assault involving domestic violence.

  • Burglary.

  • Reckless endangerment.

However, the jury found him guilty of three other offenses:

  • Theft of property.

  • Providing false information to law enforcement.

  • Reckless driving.

The distinction is important: Plumlee was not convicted of murdering Kirsten Knaus. The jury’s verdict did not erase the other convictions, but it meant that the prosecution did not secure a murder conviction.

How Long Was Cody Plumlee Sentenced to Prison?

A case summary published by MoreLaw identifies an April 8, 2022, outcome in which Plumlee received a three-year prison sentence for the vehicle theft conviction, followed by two years of supervised release. The sentences for the other convictions were to run concurrently.

This sentence should not be confused with a sentence for murder, because he was acquitted of that charge.

Where Is Cody Plumlee Now?

Questions about Plumlee’s current whereabouts have resurfaced in online searches. However, the available reporting and case summaries reviewed for this article do not establish his present residence, current custody status or whether he has completed all applicable supervision requirements.

The 2022 sentencing information provides historical context, but it is not sufficient by itself to establish where he is today. A current official correctional or court record would be needed to verify his present status.

Remembering Kirsten Knaus

Kirsten Knaus’s death was the central tragedy behind the case. Her severe injuries following the December 2020 incident and her subsequent death led to a lengthy criminal investigation and trial.

While the legal proceedings focused on determining Plumlee’s criminal responsibility for the incident, Knaus’s death remains the reason the case continues to draw attention.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who was Kirsten Knaus?

Kirsten Knaus was Cody Plumlee’s girlfriend. She suffered a severe brain injury following an incident at a Fargo residence in December 2020 and later died.

Was Cody Plumlee convicted of murder?

No. A jury found him not guilty of murder in April 2022.

What charges was Cody Plumlee convicted of?

He was convicted of theft of property, providing false information to law enforcement and reckless driving.

How long was Cody Plumlee sentenced to prison?

The available case summary reports a three-year prison sentence for the vehicle theft conviction, with the other sentences running concurrently.

Where is Cody Plumlee now?

His current whereabouts and custody status have not been established by the sources reviewed. A current official record would be needed to confirm them.

When did Kirsten Knaus die?

Knaus died later in December 2020 after suffering a severe brain injury in the December 7 incident.

Disclaimer

This article summarizes historical reporting and publicly available information about a criminal case. It distinguishes allegations from the jury’s findings and does not suggest that Plumlee was convicted of charges on which he was acquitted. Information about his current whereabouts remains unverified. This report is provided for general informational purposes only.